Introduction
Submarine Mass Transport Complexes (MTC) are geological ‘history caches’ identifying and capturing precise moments of sedimentary instability, where packages of recently deposited sediments move en masse in a single catastrophic event. The sediments are redeposited from a ‘submarine-landslide’ down the seabed slope under the influence of gravity. In our community MTCs evoke differing responses; the geophysicists are frustrated by their complex internal geometries that make their internal character hard to seismically resolve, geologists relish deciphering their subtle messages about slope stability, and explorers enjoy their top-seal and stratigraphic truncation-creating abilities. But it is perhaps to artists and poets that they appeal the most, as they can create such order from chaos of catastrophe that can seem like the structural signature of the divine.
Mass Transport Complexes
Unlike other sedimentary sequences which are deposited over extended periods of time by the pelagic deposition of grains from suspension, or remobilisation by contourite currents or deposition from episodic turbidity flows, MTCs record a single dynamic event. MTC sediments are often fine-grained muddy or silty, yet can contain entrained sandstones too, that deform as they move downslope and depending on their internal rigidity, elasticity and coherence, can be comprised of large coherent blocks (called rafts or megablocks), disrupted broken or internally deformed sediments, chaotically structured fine sediments, making for very complex internally opaque units or well-ordered but out-of-place sequences that have re-deposited on the slope or basin floor when the forces of gravitational collapse have failed to keep them moving. Whilst up-dip (from whence they came) one may observe headwall scarps, they are often accompanied down dip by compressional zones, where the moving mass encounters resistance and the section shortens (see Figures 1, 2 and 3).
If the slope gradient gently reduces then the MTC can just peter out gracefully (if chaotically), redepositing itself onto the seabed. When an active MTC hits a buttress or barrier to further motion the MTC as a body can be deflected, but if it has nowhere to go then leading part of the MTC shortens rapidly via folding or thrusting. Sometimes the entire MTC can be left prone down a slope and if it has reached the basin floor it may have a planar upper surface – as if it had no internal strength at all. The base of an MTC is just as important and can be deeply erosive or represent the decollement horizon and this can change down-slope. And it is down slope that the most beautiful of all MTC structures can be found, where the lateral movement of the MTC decolles the near surface substrate to create stunningly elegant imbricate thrust complexes which can occur at a variety of scales. There are many experts who have written about MTCs. Some fun references are given at the end of this article — just slide with them where you need to go.
Trigger happy
The fertile minds of creative geologists can generate more reasons for how an MTC can be triggered than you could shake a stick at. A shortlist includes earthquakes (even bolide impacts) if the sediments are already metastable and just need a wee push, rapid sedimentation and oversteepening so a slope is loaded faster than it can consolidate – with the interplay here between angle of repose, mechanical properties, and dewatering which also can create overpressure, basin tectonics (dynamic topography changing the relative angle of sediment repose, basin volcanics, hydrocarbon generation or fluid migration, gas hydrate dissociation (thermal or sea level fall triggered) the nature of the underlying substrate.
As up dip the collapse creates a headwall and extensional domain, the central part of the MTC is the translational domain where material is moved down dip and is largely extensional, with an underlying decollement or erosive basal surface. Downslope again, the MTC eventually encounters enough resistance that it can no longer continue moving freely, and deposition becomes the compressional domain or the toe domain. Here the moving mass is progressively shortened, producing thrust faults, folds, imbricate, pop-up structures and duplexes.
And this downdip termination can happen two quite different ways. If there is a physical barrier or ‘Hard Buttress’ for the MTC to clonk into, then shortening has to continue whilst the material is still moving into the area. This is a massive pile up of material that keeps arriving and has no-where to go. Depending on the material in the MTC and its coherence, there is capacity for all sorts of exotic thrusting duplexing and folding, and these hard-buttress scenarios are often called frontally confined systems. The other type of termination is a more passive situation ‘Soft Buttress’ where the downslope force from gravity acting on the MTC meets friction along the basal horizon to the MTC, and then the tussle is between this basal friction and the ability of the MTC to shear and for thrusts to form. When the front of the MTC stops, the remaining kinetic energy of the moving material up dip is absorbed by shortening. These are sometimes called open-ended toe or frontally emergent systems.
The third way
There is another scenario which is a version of a frontally emergent system. In the two examples shown here — Figures 1, 1A from SE India and Figure 2, 2A from the Gulf of Papua, in both cases the MTC event has had profound consequences for the sediment’s downslope where finely bedded deepwater pelagic shales deposited on the lower slope and basin floor receive a huge shove basinward. Riding on a very shallow decollement surface the top 250-500 m of sediment we can call the ‘displaced unit’ has slid forward, effectively becoming an unwitting part of the MTC.
As in the soft buttressing – when friction on the decollement is sufficient this thin displaced unit just will not move. The point where the displaced unit’s decollement surface fails, a thrust forms, and the displaced unit pops up onto the sea bed above of the unit that will not move. Yet it is still being pushed from behind, and as as it is even harder to move the displaced until along the sea bed, it too stops, and so a failure occurs behind it, a thrust is formed again. What is remarkable is that this second thrust rides to exactly the height of the first before the unit fails again behind it – so duplexes aren’t formed just imbricate thrusts. A third thrust forms repeating this again and again, so that working back from the ‘end stop’ of the displaced unit, an extraordinary number of look-alike thrusts are formed. In the case of the SE Indian example at least 40 repeats of the process occur one by one working back towards the MTC, beautifully symmetrically (Fig 1A) whilst in the Gulf of Papua there are hundreds of repeat thrusts for each event that can be mapped on the Larabanda 3D and can be seen to swarm and flow around the basin geometries of the carbonate build-ups (Figure 2A inset).
In the SE Indian example, the wavelength of the fold is twice the height of the displaced bed i.e. similar to the height of the repeated thrust (300 m) and the angle of the thrust is approximately 45o. The thrusts are always verging towards the basin. In the PNG example the wavelength of the folds (600 m) is a little longer than the height of the repeated thrust (400 m), so the thrust angle is closer to 34o. We also have examples of these exact structures developing offshore Oman 35 m in height and wavelength; however this fine detail is only apparent when the data is pre-sampled at 2mS for fine scale processing. The thrust angle is related to the coherence or strength of the displaced unit sediments, which as in both cases the sediments are pelagic shales, in similar water depths. The Mohr-Coulomb failure equation, (convolving shear stress required for failure with cohesion, effective normal stress and friction angle), suggests that a lower thrust angle indicates a less cohesive ‘displaced unit’ in Gulf of Papua than SE India (effective normal stress and failure shear stress being equal (not an unreasonable assumption but unquantified here).
The creation of these well-ordered and symmetric imbricate thrust sequences in the frontal emergent system is restricted to the displaced units — the sediments minding their own business until the MTC is dumped upon them. If there is a similar process ongoing within the MTC then it is cryptic — the internal thrusting and folding can be much more complicated, and often we cannot image it. In our third example here from the orange basin of Namibia and South Africa (Figure 3 and 3A), there are two kilometres of stacked Late Cretaceous MTC representing the catastrophic failure of the shelf and slope at least 5 times through the Coniacian stage of the Late Cretaceous.
There has been much debate about the causation of the MTC in deep-water Orange basin (even more about the gravity-driven fold and thrust belt inboard that marks the end of such instability). Earthquakes, sediment supply, and source rocks becoming mature may all play a part. However, the Pelotas Basin of Brazil is a thicker sediment accumulation, with greater sediment supply, more plausibly mature source rock and yet has few MTCs. What the Orange basin has that Pelotas does not have is regular variations in uplift due to dynamic topography. The uplift of the basin forcing slope oversteepening is the compelling MTC triggering smoking gun.
Each MTC event is clear – 200 m to 700 m thick, almost planar upper and sometimes lower surfaces, suggesting that these events were separated by relatively quiet slow deposition, presumably periods of rebuilding the shelf and slope until they failed again. What is clear is that each MTC is, on a bogglingly huge scale. The complex is mappable over 150,000 km2, with each event essentially planar or flat topped in a dip sense and each of the five MTC layers represent ca. 4 trillion kg of collapsed shelf and slope sediments. Despite the thickness of each unit varying due to erosive bases (sometime dramatically so), the top of each MTC is essentially flat over 100 km distances. Above each MTC is often a more coherently bedded Pelagic mud deposit — indicating that its not succeeding MTCs that truncate the tops of MTC units — but this is how they are deposited. Rather like the frontal emergent systems of India and Gulf of Papua, the lack of duplexing in the actual MTC seems to be a result of the strength of the materials in the MTC (i.e. they are unsurprisingly weak beds) which resort to stacking imbricate thrusts and rather than building duplexes as their strength is less than the friction forces on the thrust or decollement surface.
It is currently a matter of speculation as to whether the MTC’s infilled enough of the abyssal plain so that some material managed to climb over the outboard Mid-to-Late Cretaceous mid-ocean-ridge, west into the South American oceanic plate. As more data is acquired in the ultradeep off Uruguay and Brazil’s Pelotas basin one may anticipate that some component of material shed from the Orange Basin shelf may be observed, adding to the sequence from the east (this is not to say that tsunamis generated in Orange would not have swept the South American coastline — but that is another story...). There would be little to differentiate it from MTC being shed off the South American shelf, except perhaps the vergence of frontal emergent thrusts – should they be observed.
MTC’s may not be initiated by gravity but they are driven by gravitational potential energy which the slope converts into motion and the basal detachment permits translation. Yet it is when compression starts at the soft buttress end of the frontal emergent system, that the deformation ceases to be chaotic and abstract, and this anarchy is transformed into order, alchemically creating architectural, engineering and poetic perfection.
Acknowledgement
Thanks to Bryan Cronin for reviewing an early draft of this and making many useful suggestions.
References
- Bondevik, S., Lovholt, F., Harbitz, C., Stormo, S. and Skjerdal, G [2006] The Storegga Slide Tsunami – Deposits, Run-up Heights and Radiocarbon Dating of the 8000-Year-Old Tsunami in the North Atlantic. American Geophysical Union Meeting, Abstract. Bibcode: 2006AGUFMOS34C..01B.
- Kneller, B., Dykstra, M., Fairweather, L. and Milana, J.P. [2016] Mass-transport and slopeaccommodation: Implications for turbidite sandstone reservoirs. AAPG Bulletin, 100(2), 213-235.
- Moscardelli, L., Wood, L., Jackson, K.G. and Mann, P. [2006] Mass-transport complexes and associated processes in the offshore area of Trinidad ad Venezuela. AAPG Bulletin, 90(7), 1059-1088.

