Some things you just cannot gloss over. So, however you look at it, there is no getting away from the near futility of the COP series of meetings and how this reflects on coordinated international climate change action, not to mention more generally on our strife-torn world. During his term in office, outgoing UN Secretary-General António Guterres, to his growing dismay, witnessed energy transition losing its priority as nations focused on the challenges of global conflicts and energy security. In a valedictory address, Guterres spoke his truth: ‘You cannot build peace on a burning planet.’
We have now reached COP31, the latest annual gathering of the Conference of the Parties (COP), the supreme decision-making body of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). The inaugural meeting took place in Berlin in 1995, with German Chancellor Angela Merkel presiding. In the intervening years, probably the only remembered outcomes are the Kyoto Protocol adopted at the 1997 session. This was the first treaty to call for legally binding emission reduction targets. It was effectively replaced by the Paris Agreement of 2015, targeting net zero global emissions by mid-century and introducing Nationally Determined Contributions, where countries provide a five-year review of their climate action plans.
Over the three decades, marginal successes could be claimed for the setting of the net zero (non-binding) pledges, the international agreement to ‘transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems,' the halting of deforestation initiatives, the cutting of global methane emissions, various funding pledges to help developing countries with climate mitigation, adaptation and ‘loss and damage’ funding (at least $1.3 trillion per year by 2035), and mechanisms to measure countries’ compliance with emission reduction and other commitments.
Every one present in one capacity or another … knows that these initiatives barely scratch the surface.
Every one present in one capacity or another at COP31 in Antalya, the Turkish resort city on the Mediterranean coast, knows that these initiatives barely scratch the surface in meeting the basic issues of global warming. The ‘transitioning away from fossil fuels’ commitment was a hard-won historic compromise at COP28 in Dubai, ironic in an oil-producing country. Crucially, it still fell short of meeting calls for ‘phasing out’ of fossil fuels. At the midway point of this year’s two-week summit, there is no sign of change or any major shift in momentum.
Coal has attracted most early controversy because of the obvious conflict of interest of co-hosts, Turkey, holding the COP presidency, and Australia, leading the negotiating processes. Turkey is a major coal importer, mainly from Russia (although declining), and Australia is one of the world’s largest exporters, providing coal to Southeast Asian markets for manufacturing and thermal applications. Maybe one slogan that might stick as a climate change strategy is ‘35 by 35’ (35x35), introduced by Turkey at the meeting. It calls for a raise in electricity’s share of global energy consumption to 35% by 2035 from the existing figure of 25%, in principle lowering emissions. It would be a non-binding pledge, but critics point out there is no stipulation that the increased electricity should be generated by renewable sources. There are plenty of attendees at the meeting who will want it to stay that way.
Simon Stiell, UNFCCC chief climate negotiator, has urged countries to ‘move swiftly to the hardest issues to avoid tactical delays … There is no collective success without compromise from every party’. Unfortunately, COP’s history suggests the odds are stacked against any meaningful agreed declaration to emerge that promises significant action. For a start, the US, the world’s second largest emitter of greenhouse gases after China, is not present on orders of the Trump Administration (although former Secretary of State John Kerry and former Vice President Al Gore, along with Democratic Congress members, governors, and mayors are participating in an unofficial capacity).
The sheer size of the convention and the interest groups present is a recipe for frustration.
The sheer size of the convention and the interest groups present is a recipe for frustration. COP31 is a coming together of representatives of the 197 nations signed up to COP countries plus the EU. As the largest annual United Nations conference and one of the largest international summits in the world, the UN proudly acknowledges that it is one of the few places where almost every nation on Earth sits down for ongoing diplomatic negotiations. It also welcomes a massive ecosystem of observer groups, activists, indigenous representatives, and industry lobbyists that takes attendance up to more than 95,000 registered attendees, according to accounting by Carbon Brief.
Of these, 34,000 represent the parties (nations) in some capacity. Turkey, Brazil, Nigeria, China and Indonesia have the most registered delegates. ‘The figure for the ‘host country guests’ category has risen to 14,285 compared with 1324 at last year’s COP30. The vast majority of observers at COP31 — more than 12,000 — are representing NGOs and charities such as WWF, 350.org, and Amnesty International, as well as philanthropic organisations, such as the Rockefeller Foundation and the IKEA Foundation. There is also a huge press corps of accredited journalists, approaching 4000. Climate change activist organisations are keen to expose the dark figure, probably around 500 representatives, in some way lobbying for fossil fuels, including the oil industry, trade associations, energy finance, etc.
Unsurprisingly, every COP31 discussion topic is contested, often on rich versus poor country lines, oil producers versus committed energy transition countries, etc. Big countries like China and India have unshakeable strategies which don’t necessarily coincide with COP objectives. The agenda itself is divided into two parts. First, the Negotiating Agenda, which is driven by UNFCCC focusing on the perennial substantive issues—climate finance, mitigation issues, fossil fuel transition, adaptation and ‘loss and damage', global stocktaking of Paris Agreement progress, and carbon markets. The second part is the Action Agenda, consisting of ten non-binding themes proposed by the Turkish presidency, of which the 35x35 will be the most talked about.
Whatever the final communiqué coming out of COP31, you can be sure it has been the subject of intense negotiation in almost impossible circumstances. Hopefully it will provide a beacon of hope as the world struggles to contain the increasingly alarming impact of climate change.
Views expressed in Crosstalk are solely those of the author, Andrew McBarnet, EAGE Editor Emeritus. He can be contacted at andrew@andrewmcbarnet.com.
